Skip to content
A notebook and checklist at a Batam hawker table

Trust

How we review places in Batam

Four separate things

LISTED means a place exists in our directory, usually from OpenStreetMap data. It has not been reviewed.

VERIFIED means the business has confirmed its own details with us. It says nothing about quality.

EDITORIAL PICK means we visited and recommend it, and it carries a BatamGems Score.

SPONSORED means a business paid for placement. It is always labelled and never changes a score.

The BatamGems Score

Scores run from 0 to 10 and are only given after a visit. They combine six parts: Experience, Value, Service, Cleanliness, Atmosphere and Accessibility.

We never invent scores, reviews, prices or opening hours. If we don't know something, we leave it out.

Visitor reviews

Visitors can rate and comment once they have an account. Visitor ratings are shown separately from our own editorial picks and are never blended with them.

A reviewer's first review is checked before it appears. We remove spam, fake, abusive or off-topic reviews, and anyone can report a review. We never sell review removal or ratings.

We do not import scores from other websites.

How lists are ordered

The default "Recommended" order puts places with the most complete, checkable details first: address, phone, website and opening hours, plus places we have researched in depth.

Real visitor signals then move a place up or down: published reviews (weighted so one 5-star review cannot jump the queue), the balance of likes and dislikes (capped, one per visitor), a verified owner, and for small local businesses the permits our team has checked.

Money never changes the order, and that includes ads and affiliate commissions. Sponsored placement, if we ever sell it, is shown separately and labelled. You can always sort by name or distance instead.

How we rank

Three parts of the site are worked out by a formula, not by hand. We publish the formulas here so you can check them. None of them can be bought.

"Plan a day around" on a place page lists places to eat, see and do, shop and stay within 3 km. Each nearby place gets a score: 100 × e^(−distance in km ÷ 1.5) × how well its type suits the page × how complete its details are. A place 1.5 km away counts about a third as much as one next door. A hotel page favours food first, then sights, then shops. A restaurant page favours sights and shops, not other restaurants.

"Complete details" means places we have researched count fully, and others count between half and the full weight depending on how many of these we hold: address, phone, website, opening hours, Instagram, hotel stars and cuisine (any five give the full weight). Places below 15 points are left out, two listings of the same kind within 50 m count once, and no place is shown on more than 40 other pages, so a few big names cannot fill every list. Distances are straight lines, not road routes.

"Most viewed on BatamGems this month" counts unique visitors to each place's page on our site over the last 30 days. Recent days count more: a visit loses half its weight every 14 days. A place joins the list after 30 visitors on 5 different days, and a list only appears once 3 places qualify. It measures readers of our pages, not guests at the place, and it never uses personal data.

"Pick your base" describes what each area has most of on our map, compared with Batam as a whole. For each area and theme (food, cafes, hotels, sights, shopping, spas) we work out (n + 20 × s) ÷ (N + 20) ÷ s, where n is that theme's places in the area, N is all places in the area and s is the theme's share across Batam. The 20 stops a small area from looking strong on a handful of places. An area is "strong for" a theme when the result is 1.25 or more and it has at least 5 such places. It describes our map, not quality.

"Batam in photos" shows only places we have a real, credited photo of. Each card scores 50 × data completeness + 25 × its "Most viewed" share + 15 if the photo is our own + up to 10 from a daily shuffle that is the same for everyone. Every ten cards mixes types and areas: never two of the same type in a row, and at most four of one type or one area. After you save a place, the next ten favour places within 3 km of it, using the same distance formula as "Plan a day around". It stops every ten cards and never loads more on its own.

Halal labels

We use three labels: halal certification reported (a source says it is certified — we have not seen the certificate), states halal or no pork (not certification), and unknown. We never assume halal status from the cuisine, the owner or the staff.

Badges

Badges like Hidden Gem and Worth the Ferry are editorial judgements, not formulas. A Hidden Gem isn't simply a place with few reviews — it is somewhere we think rewards the effort of finding it.